You may not realize that moving through Massachusetts as a nonresident can trigger state licensing rules even if you lawfully carry at home. In Commonwealth v. Donnell, decided March 11, 2025, the Supreme Judicial Court struck down the Commonwealth’s prior, pre-2022 nonresident licensing scheme under G. L. c. 140, § 131F because it vested unfettered “may-issue” discretion in the State Police colonel, which failed the Supreme Court’s Bruen text-and-history test under the Second Amendment. The SJC affirmed dismissal of the § 10(a) charge that depended on that unconstitutional scheme.
The Facts of the Case
In the early morning of November 8, 2021, two Massachusetts State Police troopers responded to a single-vehicle crash on I-495 northbound near the Lowell Connector. They found the driver, Dean F. Donnell, Jr., a New Hampshire resident, sitting near his Ford Explorer and noted signs of intoxication. After field sobriety testing, troopers arrested him for operating under the influence. During a subsequent vehicle search, they discovered a handgun and ammunition. Donnell did not hold a Massachusetts nonresident license to carry.